No Surprise: New Study Confirms Five-Year Survival is a Flawed Measure for Hormone Positive Breast Cancer

By Karuna Jaggar, Executive Director 

We’ve long known that five-year survival is not a useful measure for the most common hormone positive breast cancers. And we’ve challenged major breast cancer organizations, like Susan G. Komen, for spreading misinformation about breast cancer using “5 year” data in the service of fundraising off overly positive statistics. A new meta-analysis published in the New England Journal of Medicine confirms, again, that women with estrogen-positive breast cancer cannot be considered cured after just five years.

The risk of these breast cancers recurring elsewhere (or metastasizing) remains constant from years five to 20—unlike for triple-negative breast cancer, for which 5 year data is meaningful. The new study shows that while risk of the cancer spreading is highest for women with the most lymph nodes involved, even for women with no lymph involvement, the annual rate of distant recurrence remained steady at about 1 percent for a period of five to 20 years.

The question about how long to continue hormone therapy treatment is an important question for women. While extending hormone therapy an additional five years reduces the risk of distant recurrences by a small percent, it comes with both health harms and quality of life issues that must be weighed by each individual woman, based on her preferences and priorities.

Breast Cancer Action’s past blogs can provide some more information on this topic:

The Trade-offs of Ten Years of Aromatase Inhibitors

SABCS 2016: Progress (and Lack Thereof) In Treating Hormone Positive Breast Cancer 

SABCS 2014: Ovarian Suppression and Tamoxifen for Hormone Positive Breast Cancers

SABCS 2013: The Best Treatment May Be Less Treatment

If you have questions or need information, email our Resource Liaison Zoë Christopher at info@bcaction.org or call toll free: 877-2STOPBC

This entry was posted in Articles, BCA News.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *